Adnan Syed CULTURE Games HBO serial The Case Against Adnan Syed

Review: ‘The Case of Adnan Syed’

The Case Against Adnan Syed

Surviving R. Kelly. Leaving Neverland. Lorena. The Inventor: Out for the Blood in Silicon Valley. Dialog With a Killer: The Ted Bundy Tapes. Fyre, and in addition, Fyre Fraud. 2019 has already felt flooded by must-see documentary occasion programming. New harrowing documentaries are pushed to the highest of your favourite streaming purposes’ house display each weekend. Avid streaming-TV watchers now anticipate the fixed inflow, and should discover themselves ignored of dialog in the event that they’re not maintaining. The newest of those is HBO’s The Case Towards Adnan Syed, airing in 4 elements this month, a benchmark within the historical past of our nationwide obsession with binge-entertainment-era “true crime” programming in that it revisits one of many tales which helped whet our present appetites.

Likelihood is, you already know a few of Syed’s story. When you didn’t, HBO wouldn’t have produced the movie within the first place. (Spin’s evaluation is predicated on the primary three episodes, as HBO didn’t give entry to a evaluate screener for the fourth.) Nonetheless, for posterity: In January 1999, a Korean-American 18-year-old highschool senior named Hae Min Lee was murdered in Baltimore, and Syed, her 17-year-old ex-boyfriend and a Muslim son of Pakistani immigrants, went to jail for it, based mostly largely on sudden testimony by his fairweather good friend Jay Wilds. The story entered the favored consciousness due to the primary season of Serial, the surprise-phenomenon 2014 podcast that dug into the Syed case as a kind of unsolved riddle. Serial opened up the door for administrators and producers to inform open-ended, real-life tales like this one in obsessive element, with a self-consciously high-end fashion. Serial’s tone combined homicide thriller with ethical campaign—a formulation that turned out to be extraordinarily compelling to numerous listeners.

The podcast debuted lower than 5 years in the past, nevertheless it feels for much longer in the past than that, maybe partially because of the insane fee at which the cottage business it spawned has continued to churn out new content material. Serial impressed sustained curiosity from the information media and web communities like Reddit, and have become a part of a ripple impact within the podcast and TV worlds. Different equally addictive TV programming arrived with fortuitous timing. HBO’s investigative miniseries about Robert Durst, The Jinx, turned a serious cultural phenomenon shortly afterwards, and Netflix’s first main true crime collection, Making a Assassin, arrived a number of months later. Close to-countless like-minded podcasts gained traction within the ensuing years, from Within the Darkish to S-City to Soiled John. There was a gentle firehose of trendy, forensically detailed docuseries and movie occasions, too, together with The Keepers, The Case of: JonBenét Ramsey, Wormwood, Wild Wild Nation, Kidnapped in Plain Sight, Evil Genius, and lots of extra. 2016’s staggering O.J.: Made in America helped open the doorways additional: not did these tales and morality tales have to be introduced as beforehand ignored historical past that was getting a well-deserved nearer search for the primary time. An anniversary of one of many largest human curiosity tales of our period might additionally turn into meat on the ground of the lion’s cage for leisure firms.

These days, these efforts typically embrace tales which have already been coated just lately, and in a number of totally different codecs; in any case, market-tested merchandise make for a safer guess for studios. Should-watch documentary occasions now appear to reach constantly, in an infinite wagon practice. Subsequent week, HBO will air Alex Gibney’s Theranos documentary The Inventor: Out for the Blood in Silicon Valley, recounting a story of high-stakes fraud within the medical business that we’ve already heard in numerous items of journalism, a best-selling e-book, and a podcast. (A Theranos function movie is coming quickly, starring Jennifer Lawrence as Elizabeth Holmes.) The simplest of this broad swath of programming can have highly effective real-world implications, as with Surviving R. Kelly, which intently preceded expenses of aggravated legal sexual abuse made towards the titular singer. Others, like each Fyre movies, really feel immediately a part of a wild and clumsy bum rush, with questionable ethics underpinning the entry the filmmakers gained to make their films aggressive. The essential #MeToo-era doc Discovering Neverland raised harder questions through the use of a polarizing strategy, foregrounding viscerally highly effective testimony of Michael Jackson’s alleged crimes in favor of placing these alleged crimes right into a wider context.

All of this programming suffers from being a part of a burgeoning market overflow. How redundant will firms permit their competing programming on sure tales to turn into? Years within the making, The Case Towards Adnan Syed is way from a inconsiderate try and money in on a development, and as an alternative seems to be well-researched over the course of the previous 4 years. However it looks like it’s at cross-purposes with itself, too, trying to retell, revise, and broaden the storyline of Serial suddenly however in a considerably shorter runtime. Due to its reliance on the context offered by Serial, it typically feels extra like a movie concerning the influence of the podcast than it does an examination of a homicide case which may symbolize a gross misapplication of justice.

This new extension of Syed’s narrative comes at a clumsy time. The week of the present’s premiere, the Maryland Courtroom of Appeals overturned a 2018 verdict to grant Syed a brand new trial, following his 2000 responsible verdict being vacated in 2016 resulting from proof that got here out within the wake of Serial’s large success. Rabia Chaudry, a household good friend of Syed’s and his largest authorized advocate since lengthy earlier than Serial, says on the outset of the HBO collection that she realized shortly “that Serial was not going to be a narrative that might exonerate him.” Sadly, this one in all probability gained’t both.  

Thus The Case Towards Adnan Syed mainly recollects the second season of Making a Assassin, or final yr’s follow-up episodes to the mid-aughts French true crime saga The Staircase. Reanalyzing proof and incorporating a handful of main developments within the case which have occurred since 2014, it finally seems like it’s functioning as a prolonged postscript to Serial, or an elaborately detailed set of visible footnotes to public occasions. The unique collection was a dependable visitors stream for on-line publishers, which means that most of the “new” plot occasions on this documentary have been coated intently within the media as they occurred. With the HBO documentary, at the very least, you possibly can see what all the gamers within the story appear to be with out having to Google them.

Director Amy Berg employs each established trick within the trendy documentarian’s ebook to inform her unwieldy story. There’s Steven Avery-esque voiceover of Adnan on the telephone from jail, glitchy VHS courtroom footage, semi-tearful speaking heads, candid at-home scenes of the Syed household, pretend typing and scratching sounds to dramatize the drawing up of police stories, and most distractingly, animations of Lee set to recitations from her diary. These jumbled aesthetics don’t assist the filmmakers, who’re tasked with explaining Serial’s influence on tradition and on the case itself, and successfully summarizing the content material of the 10-hour podcast, all earlier than attending to their very own new reporting: a litany of proof that makes an attempt to poke holes within the prosecution’s case towards Syed.

With the wealth of excellent supply materials, it looks like making a fascinating, abbreviated model of Serial shouldn’t be this difficult. A number of morally ambiguous characters voice a number of bizarrely conflicting accounts of the occasions of the week of Lee’s homicide, and at occasions, every of them appears plausible. Towards the backdrop of Baltimore’s racially prejudiced and in any other case poor authorized system, the case ought to be a storyteller’s dream.

However in The Case Towards Adnan Syed, Berg turns Syed’s story right into a blur of rigidity that fails to construct on itself. A glut of all-too-familiar narrative methods, meant to pique obscure suspicion or tug on the heartstrings, trigger the collection to fishtail away from something resembling dramatically highly effective continuity. It skips dramatically between storylines, leaving unfastened threads dangling and making it troublesome to recollect later that they weren’t picked up once more. Berg’s exposition fails to richly evoke Hae Min Lee as an individual, regardless of what number of ex-Woodlawn Excessive Faculty college students are placed on digital camera, how florid the animations, or what number of of her diary entries are learn in voiceover. What are supposed to really feel like detailed character research of Lee and Syed merely really feel boilerplate and even corny, because of the filmmakers’ scattershot and unresourceful strategy to storytelling and elegance.

Rabia Chaudry talking with personal investigator Tyler Maroney.
CREDIT: Courtesy of HBO

The Lee household’s wrestle over her dying solely seems in broad strokes, maybe as a result of they refused participation within the collection, simply as they did with Serial. (Necessary to recollect!) Typically, her household is even frivolously demonized, the strictness of their Korean cultural mores famous by people who find themselves conversant in them solely third-hand. A lot of the morally suspect cops and prosecutors whose contradictions would have been ripe for selecting aside in interviews additionally don’t seem, both to fall on their very own swords or defend themselves. In any case, The Case Towards Adnan Syed is brazenly telling just one aspect of the story, and doing so after Serial made that story so charged. However even Syed’s relations, to whom the filmmakers appear to have loved unfettered entry, stay sketchy figures right here, captured briefly, chronologically ambiguous, and stagey scenes of their houses.

Because the story positive aspects density within the second episode, the collection begins to maneuver like an prolonged montage. A number of the evaluation it speeds by way of feels virtually comically quotidian or basically unsuited to a cinematic remedy. The movie scrolls maniacally throughout a digital timeline of occasions, and incorporates screenshots of Reddit threads and a cursor hitting play on the Serial web site’s streaming interface. The individuals onscreen thumb by means of paperwork at a price that makes it troublesome to comply with, not to mention really feel intellectually or emotionally invested in, what they’re doing. A detail-oriented documentary is definitely not a nasty factor by any means, however the methods during which the collection is meticulous are sometimes both misplaced or unsupported by enough context. Like a Recreation of Thrones episode, or the sixth sequel in a superhero movie franchise, the stakes in The Case Towards Adnan Syed are too depending on the content material and influence of a pre-existing work.

When Serial started, it was hardly clear that one reporter’s investigation right into a potential miscarriage of justice in a largely forgotten native homicide trial would turn into a world sensation. The podcast didn’t have a preexisting attachment to a viral story, or a recognizable slot to fill. Partially, it was a few approach of telling a narrative—provocatively, bringing listeners in on the near-real-time investigation itself. Host Sarah Koenig sometimes clobbered the listener over the top with the supposed weight of sure modest breakthroughs, however she additionally put belief in her viewers to attract their very own conclusions concerning the crime. Then again, The Case Towards Adnan Syed is engineered round a perceived mutual understanding that Adnan’s case (and never Hae’s, regardless of Chaudry and others’ makes an attempt to guarantee us that also they are involved together with her story) is a Massive Deal. Maybe due to that assumption, the collection fails to make a significant argument for its personal existence.

It’s tempting to marvel, as does a regretful witness for the prosecution at one level within the doc: “What the fuck is the purpose?” Why make The Case Towards Adnan Syed within the first place? If the purpose of this type of programming is, primarily, activism, then why not make a present about one other egregiously underserved member of america jail inhabitants, one who has not already had two podcasts and countless media consideration dedicated to their plight? One reply is that there was already an viewers for this story, and the podcast that created it left area for a follow-up. Like Serial, The Case Towards Adnan Syed additionally fails to offer a transparent reply about what occurred that day in 1999, which means there’s nonetheless room for yet one more Serial sequel. It’s protected to imagine somebody is already on the market plotting it.